We provide support for litigation and other contentious proceedings, including EPO oppositions and appeals.
A granted European patent can be revoked centrally at the EPO in every designated state at once, but only for nine months following grant. Our experienced attorneys act on both sides, clearing patents that stand between you and your market, and defending the patents that are important to your business.
Offensive oppositions
You may need to clear a competitor’s patent from your path to market, or to narrow its scope before launch. We assess quickly whether an opposition is likely to succeed, and how it compares with alternative options including designing around or taking a licence. Where an opposition is the right route, we search for prior art and public prior use, examine entitlement to priority, and craft the novelty, inventive step, sufficiency and added matter attacks strategically to secure the best outcome for your business.
Defensive oppositions
Your own patent may be opposed by a competitor seeking to clear its path to market. We defend it with your commercial position in view, since the claims that survive must continue to cover the product as marketed and its approved label. We build auxiliary request sets around the commercially important claims, advise on experimental and comparative data in support of inventive step, and can advise on strategy for divisional applications.
Freedom to operate
Oppositions usually begin as a freedom-to-operate issue, for example finding a third-party application that would cover your candidate if it grants as filed. We can carry out the freedom-to-operate analysis that identifies these patent applications in the first place so that the families that matter to your pipeline can be monitored, grants that call for a decision are flagged, and further action can be taken whilst there is still time to clear the path.
Third-party observations
Anyone may submit arguments and prior art before the examining division while a patent application is still pending and this can be done anonymously. Used well, observations can be an effective way to narrow a competitor’s claims before grant and can remove the need for an opposition entirely. We advise on whether observations strengthen your position, and how to frame them if they do.
Challenges beyond Europe
EPO oppositions are often the most effective way to challenge a European patent, but they are only one route. Patents can also be challenged after grant in the US, Japan, China and other markets, each with its own procedure, timing and evidence rules. We coordinate these challenges with trusted local attorneys, so that the arguments, evidence and amendments in one forum support your position in the others.
Fractional IP counsel
Our fractional IP counsel model places a named senior patent attorney inside your team as your head of IP, watching competitor grants and the nine-month opposition window, and deciding with you which patents to challenge, which to defend and when.
Why fractional IP counsel for oppositions and appeals? The decision to oppose, or to defend, is a commercial one. Our patent directors have made those calls from inside pharma and biotech companies, so they bring the real-world industry experience that you only get working in-house to deciding which patents matter and when to act. They then work with the experienced opposition attorneys in our team, supported by Albert, rather than starting from scratch as a lone consultant would, or treating the case as a standalone legal exercise as a traditional firm might. Every challenge fits a global strategic approach across the family.
Whether you are deciding how to deal with a competitor’s newly granted patent, or looking to defend one of your own patents, contact us today to discuss how our experienced attorneys can support you.
Evolve AI
Albert: Validity, oppositions and competitive intelligence
Albert sets out a patent’s data, construes the claims and finds the weak points so that we can get to the analysis quickly.
In pharma, validity nearly always comes down to the data. Albert is a set of modules, one for each question we tend to ask of a patent, whether it belongs to a competitor, a licensing target or one of our own clients. It prepares:
- Data: each embodiment matched to its effect, the experiments behind it and the claims it supports, with a score for how good the evidence is
- Basis, support, novelty, inventive step and priority: claim by claim, against the application as filed, the data and the prior art
- Sequences and Markush formulae: lead sequences checked, generic formulae drawn out, expanded or compared with a real compound
- Construe: each claim term read against the specification
We use Albert for competitive intelligence, freedom to operate, oppositions and diligence. Albert gets us to a strategic view quickly, and we go deeper only where a particular risk warrants it. More on Albert and Albert Construe.
